Tony Greenstein | 19 August 2014 | Post Views:

Currents News          August 9, 2014 9:11
When I
was around 16 and having visited Israel as part of a Zionist Federation
programme aimed at school students, I ‘came out’ as an anti-Zionist.  There were a whole number of motives –  I broke away from the official tour to go to Jerusalem
and I made a point of talking to the Arabs of the West Bank and refusing to be blind
sided by what was, to me, obvious Israeli propaganda.
gaza 9 aug 14 demonstration
I had
also become a socialist and a Marxist and I found the universalism of these
secular heresies incompatible with the Judeo-centric emphasis of Zionism.  I had also become aware, I know not how, of
the outlines of ‘cruel Zionism’ and how it had supported the maintenance of
immigration barriers in Western countries after and even before 1945.  I listened attentively to a debate where
the  Guardian’s Michael Adams (the only
pro-Arab journalist then around) had debated with some Zionist flunkey.
But in a
provincial Jewish community in Liverpool I felt alone.   True I had good friends at the local King
David Jewish School who were lukewarm about Zionism, especially Mike Goodman
who I met up again with in NUS when he was President of Brunel students union
and I was  Vice-President of Brighton
Polytechnic and one or two others who drifted in later years into the
far-left.  But at that time there was no
one Jewish  I knew who opposed Zionism who
was Jewish.
That is
why it is a source of much pride to see the proud and assertive Jewish bloc on
the Gaza demonstration and people like Barnaby Raine.  I could only join  it at the beginning for health reasons  but thanks to groups like Jews 4 Boycotting Israeli
Goods, the Jewish anti-Zionist Network and also softer groups like the Jewish Socialists
Group and Jews for a Just Peace for Palestinians, more and more Jews are
breaking from their parents unquestioning support for all things Israel.
speech of Barnaby Raine, a 19 year old student from North London, to the  rally was magnificent.  It says virtually everything that needs to be
said about the support too many Jews still give to Zionism, as epitomised by
the despicable creatures who contacted the Jewish Chronicle to protest at their
carrying a Disaster Emergency Relief advert, when even the killers themselves,
the Israeli government, admit there is a humanitarian crisis. 
pitiful ‘Jews’ who know nothing of the prophets or Rabbi Hillel, still less the
history of Zionism itself, wish the Gazan people to suffer still more to repent
for having voted for Hamas, a group that Israel virtually created.   They believe, in line with former Israeli Deputy Defence Minister Matan Vilnai ‘Palestinians
would bring on themselves a ‘bigger shoah,” using the Hebrew word usually
reserved for the Holocaust.’ 
Tony Greenstein

Mass Rally in Hyde Park

United Kingdom’s largest demonstration for Gaza has just made history. Not only
was it the biggest protest in solidarity with Gazan civilians in the UK, but it
was also the largest in the world, at any time in history.
So many
people turned up that when the front of the march reached Hyde Park, the back
still had not left the BBC. We marched to demand an end to Israel’s barbaric
assault on Gaza, to call on the British government to implement an immediate
embargo on arms sales to Israel, and to show Palestinians facing Israel’s war
crimes that they are not alone.
Demonstration Outside BBC
protest took place on Saturday 9 August. Over 150,000 protestors marched from
BBC Broadcasting House all the way to Hyde Park, right in front of the US
Embassy along the way.
protest was not against Jews, but against the aggression of the Israeli State
against Gazan civilians. A huge number of Jewish protestors came in solidarity
with the people of Gaza. Barnaby Raine, who organized the Jewish protestors’
involvement with the march explains why he was there demanding justice:

Posted in

Tony Greenstein

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.