Tony Greenstein | 19 July 2018 | Post Views:

This is an old post dating back to 2013!

Jews Speak Out Against the Racist Double Standards of the ‘Law of Return’

There is nothing more illustrative of the racism of Israel and Zionism than the Law of Return.  As a Jew I can ‘return’ to a place I’ve no interest in living in.  But Palestinian friends have no such luxury.  They cannot return.   It is therefore excellent that there is growing Jewish opposition to Zionism despite the tants of ‘self hater’ (no we hate you!).  Like the anti-Nazi Germans who died under Hitler, Jews who oppose Zionism

 A Film Made About Jews Who Oppose Zionism
Despite an overemphasis on Neturei Kara, the Orthodox anti-Zionists, this is a good film that features among other things the young Israelis opposed to the occupation who refuse to serve in the Israel Occupation Forces, the Shministim, and also Gerald Kaufmann MP’s excellent speech when he said that his grandmother hadn’t been murdered in the ghetto she lived in by the Nazis in order that Israel could kill Palestinian grandmothers.

I am therefore very proud to be one of the founding signatories of this statement and urge all Jewish people to support it.  
Tony Greenstein
Dr. Ghada Karmi, M.D.: “An
excellent statement which gets at the heart of the Palestinian cause. All
people of conscience must sign it.”
To support the Jews for Palestinian Right
of Return statement below, please:
**Join, invite friends to, and
repost the Facebook event page 

**Repost widely on
websites and blogs:

Praise for JFPROR

Ali Abunimah
(Electronic Intifada): “Beautiful!”

Mezna Qato (US Palestinian Community Network): “Absolutely

Fatin Jarara (Al Awda-NY: The Palestine Right to Return
Coalition): “Thank you, JFPROR, for your support of the right of
return for Palestinian refugees to all of Historic Palestine and for the call
for a single democratic state, a point that must never be compromised by
Palestinians, first and foremost, or their allies.”

Max Blumenthal: ”I was proud to join so many
outstanding people in signing.”

Bramhall (Daily Censored): “Profoundly moving.”

Kevin Ovenden (Palestine solidarity activist, London): “Well
done – forwards to peace and justice, without which there can be no peace.”

Jews For Palestinian Right of Return

January 1, 2013

Palestinians, the right to return home and the right to live in dignity and
equality in their own land are not any less important than the right to live
free of military occupation.”

For more than a century, Zionists have sought
to construct a “Jewish state” through forced removal of the indigenous
Palestinian people.

In 1948,
this state was established through the Nakba (Catastrophe): erasure and
occupation of more than 500 Palestinian towns and villages, dispossession of
over 750,000 Palestinians, and a terror campaign of which the massacre at Deir
Yassin is but the most infamous example.

Since 1967, Israel has also occupied and colonized the remainder
of historic Palestine. Today, this relentless ethnic cleansing continues —
armed and financed by the U.S. and its allies — on both sides of the 1948
“Green Line.”

As a cumulative result, seventy percent of Palestinians are in exile,
the world’s largest refugee population.

Nowhere is this clearer than in Gaza, where Israel inflicts
particularly brutal collective punishment on 1.7 million people — most of them
refugees — for defiantly resisting expulsion from their homes throughout
historic Palestine.

“Pick a point, any point, along [Gaza’s]
25-mile coastline,” writes Gaza City resident Lara Aburamadan,
“and you’re seven or so miles — never more — from the other side. The other
side is where my grandparents were born, in a village that has since become
someone else’s country, off limits to me. You call it Israel. I call it the
place where the bombs come from.”

To hide these crimes and shield itself from their consequences,
the Zionist regime officially denies the Nakba, the ethical equivalent of
Holocaust denial. It has even authorized legislation to penalize those who
memorialize the Nakba — a step toward criminalizing its observance altogether.

As it is for all colonized peoples, liberation
means reversing dispossession. “The Palestinian cause,” writes
Dr. Haidar Eid in Gaza
, “is the right of return for all refugees and
nothing less.”

Return —
one of the key demands of the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) campaign
— is affirmed in U.N. resolution 194, but derives from the principle of
universal human rights and, as such, cannot be renounced or abandoned by any
body or representative; it inalienably attaches to Palestinians, both
individually and collectively.

this, even some who criticize Israel’s 1967 occupation claim that Palestinian
return is “unrealistic.”

However, solidarity means unconditional
support for the just aims of those resisting oppression. As
Palestinian journalist-activist Maath Musleh explains
: “If you think
that [return] is not possible, then you are really not in solidarity with the
Palestinian cause.”

Some also
object that refugees’ return would mean an end to the “Jewish state.” But
supporters of social justice must ask themselves how they can defend a state
whose very existence depends on structural denial of Palestinian rights.

more than a hundred leading Palestinian activists reaffirmed their opposition
all forms of racism and bigotry, including, but not limited to, anti-Semitism,
Islamophobia, Zionism, and other forms of bigotry directed at anyone, and in
particular people of color and indigenous peoples everywhere.”

Such racism and bigotry is reflected precisely
in Zionism’s attempt to erase the Palestinian people, a century long campaign
that dishonors the memory of Jewish suffering and resistance in Europe.

The moral response is clear: “There is one
geopolitical entity in historic Palestine,” writes
Palestinian journalist Ali Abunimah
. “Israel must not be allowed to
continue to entrench its apartheid, racist and colonial rule throughout that

As Jews of conscience, we call on all
supporters of social justice to stand up for Palestinian Right of Return and a
democratic state throughout historic Palestine — “From the River to the Sea” —
with equal rights for all.

The full measure of justice, upon which the hopes of all
humanity depends, requires no less.

Initial Signers


(List in formation; affiliations listed for identification only)

Max Ajl, Writer
and activist; Cornell Students for Justice in Palestine

Gabriel Ash,
International Jewish Anti-Zionist Network Switzerland

Max Blumenthal,
Journalist and author

Prof. Haim Bresheeth,
Filmmaker, photographer and film studies scholar

Lenni Brenner, Author
and antiwar activist

Mike Cushman, Convenor,
Jews for Boycotting Israeli Goods (UK)

Sonia Fayman, French
Jewish Union for Peace; International Jewish Anti-Zionist Network France

Sherna Berger Gluck, Founding
member, U.S. Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel; Israel
Divestment Campaign

Rabbi Lynn Gottlieb,
Coordinator, Fellowship of Reconciliation Peacewalks, Mural Arts in Palestine
and Shomer Shalom Network for Jewish Nonviolence

Hector Grad,
International Jewish Anti-Zionist Network Spain

Abraham Greenhouse, Blogger,
Electronic Intifada

Tony Greenstein, Jews for
Boycotting Israeli Goods (UK)

Jeff Halper, Director,
Israeli Committee Against House Demolitions (ICAHD)

Stanley Heller, Host of
“The Struggle” TV News

Tikva Honig-Parnass, Former
member of the Zionist armed forces (1948); author of False Prophets of
Peace: Liberal Zionism and the Struggle for Palestine

Adam Horowitz,

Selma James, Global
Women’s Strike; International Jewish Anti-Zionist Network UK

David Klein,
Organizing Committee, U.S. Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of

Dennis Kortheuer,
Organizing Committee, U.S. Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of
Israel; Israel Divestment Campaign; Dump Veolia LA

David Letwin, Activist
and writer; Gaza Freedom March

Michael Letwin,
Co-Founder, Labor for Palestine; Organizing Committee, U.S. Campaign for the
Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel; Al-Awda NY: The Palestine Right to
Return Coalition

Antony Loewenstein,
Australian journalist and author

Barbara Lubin, Executive
Director, Middle East Children’s Alliance

Mike Marqusee, Author
of If I Am Not for Myself: Journey of an Anti-Zionist Jew

Hajo Meyer, Auschwitz
survivor; International Jewish Anti-Zionist Network

Linda Milazzo,
Participatory journalist and educator

Prof. Ilan Pappé, Israeli
historian and socialist activist

Miko Peled, Author
of The General’s Son

Karen Pomer,
Granddaughter of Henri B. van Leeuwen, Dutch anti-Zionist leader and
Bergen-Belsen survivor

Diana Ralph, Assistant
Coordinator, Independent Jewish Voices-Canada

Dorothy Reik,
Progressive Democrats of the Santa Monica Mountains

Prof. Dr. Fanny-Michaela Reisin,
President, International League for Human Rights (German Section FIDH);
Founding member, Jewish Voice for a Just Peace – EJJP Germany

Rachel Roberts, Civil
rights attorney and writer

Ilana Rossoff,
International Jewish Anti-Zionist Network

Carol K. Smith, Activist
and civil rights attorney

Lia Tarachansky,
Director, Seven Deadly Myths

Hadas Thier,
Contributing author of The Struggle for Palestine; Israeli-born
daughter and granddaughter of Nazi Holocaust survivors

Dr. Abraham Weizfeld, Jewish
People’s Liberation Organization (Montréal)

Sherry Wolf, Author
and public speaker; International Socialist Organization; Adalah-NY

Marcy Winograd, Former
Congressional peace candidate; public school teacher

Dr. Roger van Zwanenberg,
Non-Executive Director, Pluto Books Ltd.
Additional Signers
(Complete list atAffiliations listed for identification only.)

 Vancouver, BC, Independent Jewish Voices

Deborah Agre, Berkeley, CA, Middle East Children’s

Seymour Alexander, Slough, Jews for Justice
for Palestinians UK

Ruth BaderAustralia, German-Jewish/Australian, daughter of Holocaust

Adam Balsam, Independent Jewish Voices Canada

Moran Barir, Human rights activist, Jerusalem

Ronnie Barkan, Tel-Aviv, Boycott from Within

Nora Barrows-Friedman, Journalist

Dalit Baum, Israeli feminist teacher and activist

Medea Benjamin, Codirector, Codepink

Mark Berman, Playwright

Rima Berns-McGown, Toronto, Writer and Adjunct
Faculty, University of Toronto at Mississauga

Elizabeth Block, Toronto, Independent Jewish

Audrey Bomse, National Lawyers Guild, Free Gaza

Dennis Brasky, Professor – Political Science – Rutgers

Estee Chandler, Founding Member, Jewish Voice
for Peace, L.A. Chapter

David Comedi, Tucumán, Argentina

Prof. Roger Dittmann, CSU Fullerton

Mark Elf, Jews sans frontieres

Prof. Sam Farber, NYC

Deborah Fink, UK, Jews for Boycotting Israeli Goods

Alexei Folger, Jewish Voice for Peace, Bay Area

Maxine Fookson, Portland, Oregon, Jewish Voice
for Peace

Racheli Gai, Tucson Women in Black, Jewish Voice for

Kamran Ghasri, Israel Divestment Campaign

Dr. Terri Ginsberg, NYC; film scholar; Committee for
Open Discussion of Zionism

Neta Golan, Palestinian Territories, ISM

Nathan Goldbaum, ISO, Caucus of Rank-and-File
Educators, Chicago Teachers Union

Steve Goldfield, Ph.D., Oakland, CA, Former
chair, Palestine Solidarity Committee, former editor, Palestine Focus

Jean R. Goldman, Miami Beach, Women in Black

Sue Goldstein, Toronto, Women in Solidarity with Palestine

Marty Goodman, NYC, Former Executive Board member,
Transport Workers Union Local 100

Heidi Grunebaum, Cape Town

Cathy Gulkin, Toronto, Independent Jewish Voices, Queers
Against Israeli Apartheid

Georges Gumpel, Union Juive Française pour la

Freda Guttman, Montreal, Tadamon!

Evelyn Hecht-Galinski, Author and journalist, Germany

Annette Herskovits, Berkeley, Holocaust survivor,
writer, and activist

Rebecca Hom, International Jewish Anti-Zionist

Bec Hynek, Sydney, Australia, Socialist

Jews Opposing Zionism, Not In Our Name – NION (Canada)

Riva Joffe, London, Jews Against Zionism

Ramsey Judah, Los Angeles activist and Immigration Rights

Alex Kane, Assistant Editor, and World
editor, AlterNet

Dan Kaplan, Executive Secretary, AFT Local 1493, San
Mateo, CA Community College Federation of Teachers

Asaf Kedar, Zochrot

Alice Diane Kisch, Emerryville, CA, Jewish Voice
for Peace

Bud Korotzer, Brooklyn

Yael Korin, Campaign to End Israeli Apartheid,
Southern California

Steve Kowit, American poet, Professor emeritus,
Southwestern College

L.A. Jews for Peace

Sylvia Laale, Ottawa

Stephen Landau, Translator and
publisher, White Plains, NY

David Landy, Ireland Palestine Solidarity Campaign

Melanie Lazarow, University of Melbourne

Howard Lenow, Sudbury, MA, Union Attorney, Founder
American Jews For A Just Peace

Leah Levane, London, Jews for Justice for Palestinians

Daniel Levyne, France, UJFP

Brenda Lewis, Guelph, Ontario, child of Holocaust survivor

Abby Lippman, Montreal, Professor Emerita, McGill

Jennifer Loewenstein, Madison

Henry Lowi, IDF veteran

Alex Lubin, Professor, American University of Beirut

Helga Mankovitz, Kingston, ON, Independent Jewish

Eli Marcus, Occupied Palestine

Richard Marcuse, West Vancouver, BC, Independent
Jewish Voices

Peter Melvyn, Critical Jewish Voice, Vienna

Waldo Mermelstein, Sao Paulo

Gail Miller, NY, Passenger, U. S. Boat to Gaza–The
Audacity of Hope

Prof. Hilton Obenzinger

Akiva Orr, Matzpen

Peter Rachleff, Saint Paul, Professor of
History, Macalester College

Zohar Chamberlain Regev, Dúrcal, Granada, Spain

Fanny-Michaela Reisin, Jewish Voice for a Just Peace –
EJJP Germany

Ernest Rodker, Jews for Justice for Palestinians, UK

Professor Jonathan Rosenhead, Chair, British Committee
for the Universities of Palestine

Martha Roth, Vancouver BC, Independent Jewish Voices

Cheyl A. Rubenberg, Boca Raton, Professor (retired)

Leslie Safran, London

Margot Salom, Brisbane Australia, Just Peace for Palestine

Christiane Schomblond, Brussels, Belgium, professor
retired from University of Brussels

Ralph Schoenman, Vallejo, CA., Author: Hidden
History of Zionism

Yossi Schwartz, Haifa, Internationalist
Socialist League

Amanda Sebestyen, International Jewish
Anti-Zionist Network UK, JfJfP, JBIG, IJV

Sid Shniad, Vancouver, BC, National Steering Committee,
Independent Jewish Voices

Mya Shone, Author, The Hidden History of Zionism and
other works

Abba A. Solomon, Author of The Speech, and Its Context

Peter Sporn, Oak Park, Illinois, Arab Jewish Partnership
for Peace and Justice in the Middle East

Marsha Steinberg, BDS LA for Justice in Palestine

Cy & Lois Swartz, Philadelphia, Grandparents for
Peace in the Middle East

Prof. Barry Trachtenberg

Matthew Taylor, Berkeley, founding member, Young
Jewish and Proud group within Jewish Voice for Peace

Steve Terry, Criminal defense attorney, Brooklyn

Lily van den Bergh, Documentary filmmaker &
organiser, Women in Black  The Netherlands

Dominique Ventre, French Jewish Union for Peace;
International Jewish Anti-Zionist Network France

Judith Weisman, Toronto, Independent Jewish
Voices, Not in Our Name

Suzanne Weiss, Toronto

Naomi Wimborne-Idrissi, Founder member, Jews for
Boycotting Israeli Goods

Tamar Yaron, Kibbutz Hazorea, Israel, founder &
moderator: Encounter-EMEM for international Israel-Palestine peace activities

Posted in

Tony Greenstein

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.