Tony Greenstein | 29 October 2026 | Post Views:

|

MEMO in Conversation with Benjamin Moser 

Arthus J Balfour, Zionist hero & author of the Balfour Declaration, was an Imperialist & White Supremacist

Anti-Zionism, A Jewish History: Benjamin Moser with Rashid Khalidi | Cullman Center

Jewish author describes Zionism as a racially exclusive movement

Why Many Jews hate Zionism: The Long History of Jewish anti-Zionism

Christian Zionism and the ‘Return’ of the Jews

Zionism was seen as a form of Jewish anti-Semitism

Manis Friedman is an influential Rabbi in the Lubavitch Hasidic Movement – Apart from Killing Palestinian Children He Believes That Child Sex Abuse is No Worse Than Diarrhea

The Zionists don’t give up in their campaign to equate Zionism and anti-Semitism as the bogus report above demonstrates

The Snow Queen

Benjamin Moser in Conversation with Ahdaf Soueif

Ronnie Kasrils – a Living Legend and Fighter Against Apartheid & Zionism

Benjamin Moser in Conversation with Ahdaf Soueif

Hannah Arendt

“Liberal Zionists Are the Real Enemy” | Benjamin Moser & Barry Malone 

See also

Anti-Zionism: A Jewish History by Benjamin Moser review – the deep roots of a contemporary movement

Interview – The Paris Review – Plan B Is Extremely Dangerous: Benjamin Moser on Anti-Zionism By Krithika Varagur September 22, 2026

Posted in

Tony Greenstein

16 Comments

  1. David Avery on 29/10/2026 at 3:55pm

    I was going to ask you Tony, what you thought of this, but recently got it. But have read it yet!

  2. Tim Martin on 30/10/2026 at 4:27pm

    Thanks for this Tony – also of historic contextual interest is the role that Arthur Balfour played in the account by John P Cafferky ‘Lord Milner’s second War’ …

  3. Anthony Posner on 07/11/2026 at 8:20am

    Why did Moser exclude Trotsky? And might he have survived if he had gone to Palestine rather than Mexico? It is, moreover, worth noting that as the 1930’s progressed Trotsky seemed ambivalent about the necessity of a Jewish place of refuge. Perhaps that was due to the fact that his four children predeceased him, victims of Stalin’s animosity?

    • Tony Greenstein on 07/11/2026 at 6:32pm

      I have no idea why Moser excluded Trotsky. Possible because anti-Zionism wasn’t his main contribution to political life?

      • Anthony Posner on 08/11/2026 at 1:01pm

        Moser did not analyse the political divide between the Russian Jewish Bolsheviks and the Russian Jewish Zionists. Jewish anti-zionists tend to be Marxists and for some reason Moser seems unwilling to celebrate this fact. If he had it would have forced him to write an accurate history of Jewish anti-zionism, a task which intellectually he knew was beyond his grasp. Moreover, it would have inevitably alienated the more Islamist orientated anti-zionists who find Marxism unpalatable.

      • Anthony Posner on 08/11/2026 at 2:04pm

        A non-polemical history of political Jewish anti-zionism up until now, would be an important book. It should also analyse political Zionism in a lucid, balanced manner. It should accurately and dispassionately discuss the issues without jumping on any bandwagon. The historian/ political scientist who could complete such a task would perhaps have written an important book rather than the polemic that Moser has disingenuously provided.

        • Tony Greenstein on 09/11/2026 at 3:02am

          This is complete nonsense. There is no such thing as ‘non-polemical’ or neutrality. Ben Moser’s is a fine book and I have removed your previous personal attack on him. There is nothing disingenuous about his book. It is a fine work and I have learnt much from it

          • Anthony Posner on 09/11/2026 at 11:22am

            Tony, I appreciate your replies. Do you think that Moser has an understanding of either European history or Jewish Europesn history? As the 20th century progressed, European Jews could look to Marxism or Zionism to “save” them and Moser ignores a discussion of this binary choice. Please explain what has most impressed you most about Moser’s book from your perspective as an anti-zionist Marxist.



          • Anthony Posner on 09/11/2026 at 11:56am

            Tony, from your perspective, is it possible to write a history of political, rather than religious anti-zionism, which isn’t inherently some sort of polemic? If you had to recommend one historian who has written about the Third Reich, who would that be?



  4. Anthony Posner on 07/11/2026 at 10:46am

    Another Green party motion… Judaism is a religion of genocide. Tony could draft it with help from Lubna Speitan etc. It would create quite a stir but might pick up some Muslim voters.

    • Tony Greenstein on 07/11/2026 at 6:31pm

      today Judaism is a religion of genocide, that is true

      • Anthony Posner on 09/11/2026 at 12:46pm

        Tony, let’s conclude that contemporary Judaism is “a religion of genocide”. How can it best be confronted? Should the synagogues now be closed? What is the best response from a Marxist anti-zionist perspective?

  5. Anthony Posner on 09/11/2026 at 11:43am

    Tony, assume that you had been a relatively prosperous German Jew, living in Munich during the late 1930s and had managed to not get yourself arrested. Let’s also imagine that you could not have emigrated to Brighton because the Brits didn’t want you. If the Nazis had given you the opportunity to escape to Palestine would you have taken it, assuming that you were a trenchant anti-zionist. Dachau or Tel Aviv- which would you have chosen?

  6. Anthony Posner on 09/11/2026 at 1:11pm

    Tony I have read your excellent review of Chotiner’s review – it is a pity that it wasn’t published. What is interesting when one connects Zionism to Nazism, is that both Herzl.and Hitler took cognizance of Vienna’s Mayor, Karl Lueger. Vienna certainly had an impact on both of them and Hitler lived there a few years after Herzl , an important fact that Moser has ignored. Does Moser mention Churchill’ s article on Zionism and Bolshevism written in 1920?. Perhaps, it passed him by? Although you are certain that Moser has written an impressive book, why did he ignore an analysis of Marx’s essay On The Jewish Question which suggests that the Jew is the archetypal capitalist? If you had written a history of Jewish anti-zionism, would you have discussed these points or would you have viewed them as irrelevant?

  7. Anthony Posner on 09/11/2026 at 2:01pm

    Tony, what is unavailable is a complete history of political anti-zionism. . It is a massive subject but somebody should attempt it. To make it relatively compact, it could start with Herzl and end in 2026. It would be essential reading. Have you ever thought about writing it for the general public, world-wide? You really have the requisite knowledge and it could have mass appeal. ..Trotsky, Edwin Montague , Stalin, The Grand Mufti of Jerusalem , Saddam Hussein, Ayatollah Khomeini, Arafat, Nasser, Fidel Castro, Gadaffi, The Assads, Hezbollah, Hamas, Leila Khaled, Osama Bin Laden, Jeremy Corbyn, Zack Polanski, David Miller, Lubna Speitan, Palestine Action, Ilan Pappe, Greta Thunberg, Ronnie Kasrils to name just a few. Of course, there are many more more that can be featured. Why not write it because it such an interesting diversity of characters, political movements , wars etc. Hijackings, The Munich Olympics,Oct 7th etc.

    • Tony Greenstein on 10/11/2026 at 6:46am

      Anthony

      many of the people you mention above I do not consider anti-Zionists. They might be anti-imperialists though even that is doubtful. I see little point in such a wide project and I have no time to do it. A history of Jewish anti-Zionism would be useful but would also be a mammoth task

Leave a Comment





This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.