The Myth of the Jewish Nation Meets New York University

I’ve already covered Shlomo Sand’s important book on the Myth of the Jewish Nation. ‘Secular’ Zionism was predicated on the right of ‘return’ of the Jews to a ‘holy land’ that was given by god to his own chosen people. Unsurprisingly ‘secular’ Zionism – always a contradiction in terms has all but disappeared as a…

Read More

Israel’s Lack of Legitimacy

An interesting article by Haaretz commentator, Ari Shavit, on how Israel’s strength is being undermined politically by its growing illegitimacy. Tony Greenstein Israel needs legitimacy to wage war and peace By Ari Shavit, Haaretz Correspondent It seems as if everything is fine. Israel’s borders are quiet, the state is stable, the economy is recovering. Hezbollah…

Read More

Defend Jonathan Hoffman!

More than once in the past few months I had wondered why the stuffed shirts of the English Zionist Federation had appointed an activist who didn’t mind getting his hands dirty, when Jonathan Hoffman surfaced as its Vice-Chair. I must confess it has been a pleasant surprise. Whenever a demonstration is getting a bit tired…

Read More

A Petition to A Quisling – It’s Time to Go

Below is an open letter to the Palestinian Quisling Leader, Mahmud Abbas. It is signed by many well known supporters of the Palestinians, including Noam Chomsky, and key Palestinian activists like Omar Barghouti. If you agree, sign! Tony Greenstein An Open Letter to Mahmud ‘Abbas on the Goldstone Report: We are a diverse group of…

Read More

Zionism Boycotts the Funeral of Marek Edelman

A sad farewell to Marek Edelman – the last surviving Commander of the Bund. The article below describes his funeral in Warsaw, where he was buried, although he lived in Poland’s second city, Lodz. It is noticeable that apart from the attendance of Shevach Weiss, a previous Israeli Ambassador to Poland, in his personal capacity,…

Read More

Marek Edelman – The best, and last, of an era

An interesting obituary for Marek Edelman in Ha’aretz by someone who is clearly a Revisionist Zionist but who nonetheless recognises the contribution of Marekt Edelman and the fact that he remained a determined opponent of Zionism to the last. Not for him the ‘negation of the Diaspora’ and other anti-Semitic notions. Tony Greenstein Marek Edelman…

Read More