Learning from Galileo and the Inquisition
In 1633 Galileo was
convicted for Heresy by the Inquisition for arguing in support of the
Copernican belief that the Earth revolved around the Sun. This was despite the fact that most of the scientists
and philosophers at the time were convinced that the Aristotelian concept of a stationery
Earth, around which the Sun and planets moved, was false.
convicted for Heresy by the Inquisition for arguing in support of the
Copernican belief that the Earth revolved around the Sun. This was despite the fact that most of the scientists
and philosophers at the time were convinced that the Aristotelian concept of a stationery
Earth, around which the Sun and planets moved, was false.
 |
| Galileo faced the Inquisition for daring to challenge accepted orthodoxies |
Galileo’s problem was
that scientific evidence, logic and observation conflicted with the ideological
needs of the system he lived under. A
reordering of the heavens challenged the very basis of the theological precepts
by which Papal rule was maintained.
 |
| The Political Equivalent of the Copernican Theory is now a Heresy in Labour |
Galileo wrote to the
German mathematician Johannes Kepler ‘”what would you say of the learned
here, who, replete with the pertinacity of the asp, have steadfastly refused to
cast a glance through the telescope? What shall we make of this?
Shall we laugh, or shall we cry?”
German mathematician Johannes Kepler ‘”what would you say of the learned
here, who, replete with the pertinacity of the asp, have steadfastly refused to
cast a glance through the telescope? What shall we make of this?
Shall we laugh, or shall we cry?”
I am
reminded of Galileo’s travails since the heresy hunt in the Labour Party makes
it an expulsion offence to even hint that Zionism is racist or to compare
Israel in any way with the Nazis. Indeed even to pretend that Israel is anything other than a fine, democratic example to the
rest of the world, a beacon of freedom, is not only reason enough for
suspension but prima facie evidence of ‘anti-Semitism’.
reminded of Galileo’s travails since the heresy hunt in the Labour Party makes
it an expulsion offence to even hint that Zionism is racist or to compare
Israel in any way with the Nazis. Indeed even to pretend that Israel is anything other than a fine, democratic example to the
rest of the world, a beacon of freedom, is not only reason enough for
suspension but prima facie evidence of ‘anti-Semitism’.
 |
| Like Aristotle’s Theory, the idea that Zionism is a wonderful movement opposed to all forms of racism is the New Labour orthodoxy |
In the
Labour Party today there is a similar refusal to look through the telescope or
perhaps it is the turning of a Nelsonian blind eye to the Israeli state as it
actually exists. Israel is a state which
permanently rules over four and a half million Palestinians, who cannot be granted
the vote or any measure of civil rights, because that is incompatible with a
‘Jewish State’. It is a situation whereby
there are two different systems of law– one for Palestinians and another for
Jewish settlers. Even within the
non-existent Green Line, Israel’s own Arab citizens are there on sufferance,
with a plurality of Jewish voters wanting them expelled. Apartheid may not be officially declared, but
it is practical politics.
Labour Party today there is a similar refusal to look through the telescope or
perhaps it is the turning of a Nelsonian blind eye to the Israeli state as it
actually exists. Israel is a state which
permanently rules over four and a half million Palestinians, who cannot be granted
the vote or any measure of civil rights, because that is incompatible with a
‘Jewish State’. It is a situation whereby
there are two different systems of law– one for Palestinians and another for
Jewish settlers. Even within the
non-existent Green Line, Israel’s own Arab citizens are there on sufferance,
with a plurality of Jewish voters wanting them expelled. Apartheid may not be officially declared, but
it is practical politics.
 |
| Torquemada’s agent Harry Gregson, Labour’s SE Regional Organiser |
The
Labour Party now exists in a parallel universe whereby black is white and truth
is false. The laws of logic have been
suspended. How else can one describe a
situation whereby those who support the world’s only apartheid state are the
ones defining what is and is not racism?
Labour Party now exists in a parallel universe whereby black is white and truth
is false. The laws of logic have been
suspended. How else can one describe a
situation whereby those who support the world’s only apartheid state are the
ones defining what is and is not racism?
In
recent weeks, Ken Livingstone has been suspended for mentioning the
relationship of the Nazis to the Zionists, David Watson has been suspended for claiming
that Zionism is racist and I have been suspended for, among other things,
claiming that Zionism is a Jewish form of anti-Semitism.
recent weeks, Ken Livingstone has been suspended for mentioning the
relationship of the Nazis to the Zionists, David Watson has been suspended for claiming
that Zionism is racist and I have been suspended for, among other things,
claiming that Zionism is a Jewish form of anti-Semitism.
 |
| When Peter Kyle MP won a seat in Hove against the Conservatives it was said that the most right-wing candidate had won! Calling for the deselection of this arch-privatiser is now a disciplinary offence |
The
latter is a question of fact. Although Zionist
supporters today claim to oppose anti-Semitism, no historian of Zionism can be
unaware that both anti-Semites and Zionists shared the same prejudices against diaspora
Jewry. As Jacques Doron notes in Classic Zionism and Modern Anti-semitism:
Parallels and influences (1883-1914) (Journal of Israeli History, no. 8,
1.9.83., p.171)
latter is a question of fact. Although Zionist
supporters today claim to oppose anti-Semitism, no historian of Zionism can be
unaware that both anti-Semites and Zionists shared the same prejudices against diaspora
Jewry. As Jacques Doron notes in Classic Zionism and Modern Anti-semitism:
Parallels and influences (1883-1914) (Journal of Israeli History, no. 8,
1.9.83., p.171)
‘It
cannot be denied that the Jewish self-criticism so widespread among the German
Zionist intelligentsia often seemed dangerously similar to the plaints of the
German anti-Semites.’
 |
| Tomás de Torquemada – Hero of Labour’s Blairite civil service |
There is
a universal consensus in the media, that extends from the Guardian to the Daily
Mail, that anyone who criticises Zionism is anti-Semitic. The mere suggestion however that Israel is
anything other than the purest form of Athenian democracy is like to result in
Labour’s Inquisition bearing down on them, presided over by Torquemada in the
form of John Mann MP. Events however have a habit of defying even the most
prosaic of ideologues.
 |
| John Stolliday – the hatchetman in charge of the leaky Compliance Unit |
In the
past week alone Israel’s Deputy Chief of Staff, General Yair Golan has compared
developments in Europe, particularly Germany in the 1930’s to Israel today. [IDF general in bombshell speech: Israeltoday shows signs of 1930s Germany, Jerusalem Post, 4.5.16.] Yair’s speech at a ceremony remembering the Holocaust
led to a series of events which culminated in the removal of Moshe Yalon as Israel’s
Defence Minister.
past week alone Israel’s Deputy Chief of Staff, General Yair Golan has compared
developments in Europe, particularly Germany in the 1930’s to Israel today. [IDF general in bombshell speech: Israeltoday shows signs of 1930s Germany, Jerusalem Post, 4.5.16.] Yair’s speech at a ceremony remembering the Holocaust
led to a series of events which culminated in the removal of Moshe Yalon as Israel’s
Defence Minister.
Yalon was no slouch
when it came to killing Palestinians but his replacement, Avigdor Lieberman is the
Israeli equivalent of Isis. Lieberman
has previously called for the beheading of ‘disloyal’ Israeli Arabs. [Lieberman: Disloyal Israeli Arabs Should Be
Beheaded and the drowning of thousands of Palestinian prisoners in the Dead Sea, Lieberman Blasted for Suggesting Drowning Palestinian Prisoners]
when it came to killing Palestinians but his replacement, Avigdor Lieberman is the
Israeli equivalent of Isis. Lieberman
has previously called for the beheading of ‘disloyal’ Israeli Arabs. [Lieberman: Disloyal Israeli Arabs Should Be
Beheaded and the drowning of thousands of Palestinian prisoners in the Dead Sea, Lieberman Blasted for Suggesting Drowning Palestinian Prisoners]
Lieberman
agreed to join Netanyahu’s Likud coalition on the basis that he could introduce
the death penalty. Naturally the death
penalty will only apply to Palestinians since only Military Courts, which have
a conviction rate of some 99.7%, will have the power to impose it. Jewish settler terrorists are tried in civil
courts.
agreed to join Netanyahu’s Likud coalition on the basis that he could introduce
the death penalty. Naturally the death
penalty will only apply to Palestinians since only Military Courts, which have
a conviction rate of some 99.7%, will have the power to impose it. Jewish settler terrorists are tried in civil
courts.
 |
| Having the Jewish Labour Movement presiding over ‘anti-racism’ training is like having Britain’s biggest mass murderer, Dr Harold Shipman, in charge of developing a policy on medical ethics |
We have an
Alice in Wonderland situation in the Labour Party whereby the Jewish Labour
Movement, which supports the Israeli state and its founding ideology, Zionism,
is to be put in charge of anti-racism training by Baroness Royall, who
investigated ‘anti-Semitism’ at Oxford University Labour Club. Its akin to having the late Dr Shipman given
responsibility for developing a course in medical ethics. The JLM is affiliated to the World Zionist
Organisation, which is responsible for the funding and development of
settlements in the West Bank. Its
institutions are key to the maintenance of Israeli Apartheid, both in Israel
itself and the Occupied Territories. Since
the JLM excludes from membership anyone who is not a Zionist or supporter of
the Israeli state, it would be more honest to call it the Zionist Labour
Movement.
Alice in Wonderland situation in the Labour Party whereby the Jewish Labour
Movement, which supports the Israeli state and its founding ideology, Zionism,
is to be put in charge of anti-racism training by Baroness Royall, who
investigated ‘anti-Semitism’ at Oxford University Labour Club. Its akin to having the late Dr Shipman given
responsibility for developing a course in medical ethics. The JLM is affiliated to the World Zionist
Organisation, which is responsible for the funding and development of
settlements in the West Bank. Its
institutions are key to the maintenance of Israeli Apartheid, both in Israel
itself and the Occupied Territories. Since
the JLM excludes from membership anyone who is not a Zionist or supporter of
the Israeli state, it would be more honest to call it the Zionist Labour
Movement.
It is part
of the new political gospel that the Labour Party is being submerged in a
tsunami of anti-Semitism. What we are
witnessing is the manufacturing of consent that flies in the face of all the
evidence. It is the perfect example of
Marx’s dictum that the ruling ideas in any society are the ideas of the ruling
class. The existence of ‘anti-Semitism’
is assumed as a given. It is above and
beyond challenge in the mainstream press and media, despite the lack of any
evidence for it. How Israel lobby manufactured UK Labour Party’santi-Semitism crisis
of the new political gospel that the Labour Party is being submerged in a
tsunami of anti-Semitism. What we are
witnessing is the manufacturing of consent that flies in the face of all the
evidence. It is the perfect example of
Marx’s dictum that the ruling ideas in any society are the ideas of the ruling
class. The existence of ‘anti-Semitism’
is assumed as a given. It is above and
beyond challenge in the mainstream press and media, despite the lack of any
evidence for it. How Israel lobby manufactured UK Labour Party’santi-Semitism crisis
Almost everyday
people who criticises Zionism, the movement which founded the Israeli state, are
being suspended for ‘anti-Semitism’. Although
it is anti-Semitic to equate Jews and Zionism, anyone who criticises the latter
is deemed anti-Semitic!
people who criticises Zionism, the movement which founded the Israeli state, are
being suspended for ‘anti-Semitism’. Although
it is anti-Semitic to equate Jews and Zionism, anyone who criticises the latter
is deemed anti-Semitic!
Jackie
Walker, the Vice-Chair of Momentum, has been suspended for mentioning the
involvement of Jews in financing the slave trade. She is herself both Black and Jewish. [Jackie has since been reinstated] It is one of Zionism’s myths that anti-Semitism
is a seamless continuum of Jewish oppression for two thousand years. Jews were always victims never perpetrators. It
was this, the ‘lachrymose version of Jewish history’ that Salo Baron, perhaps the greatest Jewish
historian of the 20th century railed against.
I was myself suspended on March 18th for having made comments,
the details of which Labour’s Compliance Unit initially refused to give me,
despite leaking them to The Telegraph which printed them on 2nd April. [Activist who derides critics as ‘Zionist scum’ admitted to Labour in latest anti-Semitism scandal to hit Party]
the details of which Labour’s Compliance Unit initially refused to give me,
despite leaking them to The Telegraph which printed them on 2nd April. [Activist who derides critics as ‘Zionist scum’ admitted to Labour in latest anti-Semitism scandal to hit Party]
I will shortly be appearing before an investigation meeting. It would appear that the Acting Regional
Organiser for the South-East Harry Gregson, has gone into overdrive trying to
find some incriminating evidence against me.
It is a strange process whereby you first suspend someone and then begin
trying to find the evidence to justify the suspension.
Organiser for the South-East Harry Gregson, has gone into overdrive trying to
find some incriminating evidence against me.
It is a strange process whereby you first suspend someone and then begin
trying to find the evidence to justify the suspension.
One of the charges against me is that I wrote a blog post entitled ‘Israeli Policy is to wait for the remaining Holocaust survivors to die’ This was deemed
such a terrible accusation by Gregson that it must be anti-Semitic.
It is of course a terrible accusation but exactly the same charge is
made in an article in Israel’s Ha’aretz newspaper! Israel Is Waiting for Its Holocaust Survivors to Die
made in an article in Israel’s Ha’aretz newspaper! Israel Is Waiting for Its Holocaust Survivors to Die
It is beyond dispute that Israel is parsimonious in the extreme in withholding
benefits from holocaust survivors.
Thousands of holocaust survivors in Israel live in dire poverty, forced
to choose between heat and food.
benefits from holocaust survivors.
Thousands of holocaust survivors in Israel live in dire poverty, forced
to choose between heat and food.
Israel has received billions of shekels in reparations from the German
state. It has preferred to spend them on holocaust memorials and holocaust
‘education’, to say nothing of weaponry rather than on the holocaust survivors
themselves.
The true reason for my suspension though may lie in one other charge
that I am facing, namely that I have called for the deselection of Peter Kyle,
the New Labour MP for Hove. Kyle is
someone who believes fervently in private involvement in the NHS. He voted for bombing Syria and is a darling
of the Progress wing of Labour.
that I am facing, namely that I have called for the deselection of Peter Kyle,
the New Labour MP for Hove. Kyle is
someone who believes fervently in private involvement in the NHS. He voted for bombing Syria and is a darling
of the Progress wing of Labour.
The anti-Semitism witch-hunt in the Labour Party has one overriding
purpose. It is not just about sanitising
Israel. Its primary purpose is the
removal of the Jeremy Corbyn leadership of the Party. Co’s appeasement of the Right in the Labour
Party is a recipe for defeat. Its only
effect is to whet the appetite of Labour’s McCarthyists.
Tony Greenstein
Posted in Blog
