Sadism and Cruelty are Embedded in the DNA of Zionism
The Decision to Refuse Khalida Jarrar, a Political Prisoner, Permission to Attend Her Daughter’s Funeral is an act of Judeo-Nazis
Nothing emphasises the cold, racist contempt that Zionism holds for Palestinians than the decision to prevent Khalid Jarrar permission to attend her daughter’s funeral. It is inconceivable that a Jewish prisoner in Israel would be treated in the same manner.
Khalid has been repeatedly gaoled for her political activity, membership of the Marxist Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine. Most of the time this has been ‘Administrative Detention’ i.e. what was called in Ireland, internment without trial. From 2nd July 2017 to 28 February Khalida was held under Administrative Detention.
The PFLP has a political and a military wing. Khaled belongs to its political wing. She is an elected member of the Palestinian parliament but that has not prevented the ‘democratic state’ of Israel from gaoling her for nakedly political reasons. There is no ‘security’ issue, the usual justification for racism in Israel.
As Omar Shakir of Human Rights Watch said
Israel claims to be a democratic state but it gaols hundreds of Palestinians on the West Bank (and a few now in Israel too) without even the formality of a military trial, for 6 months at a time. This includes children. No offence need ever be committed. Political opposition to the occupation is all that is required.
Israel, which helped create Hamas, has no problem with conservative Islam (despite the pretence that Hamas is the devil incarnate, Netanyahu had an informal agreement with them) as demonstrated by the inclusion in a governing coalition, for the first time ever, of an Arab Party Ra’am, the offshoot of Egypt’s Moslem Brotherhood.
Secular and in particular leftist Palestinian groups are anathema to all wings of Zionism, left and right.
Contrast this with Elor Azaria, the Kahanist soldier who executed an unconscious Palestinian, Abdel Fatah al-Sharif, lying on the ground. Azaria became a hero to the majority of Israelis on his release from prison. They even printed his ugly face on supermarket bags.
The face of murderer Elor Azaria decorated plastic bags in Israel
As Ha’aretz put it, Azaria became a ‘poster child for Israel’s moral erosion.’ Because of the international attention that the case aroused, the Israeli Military was forced to jail him for 9 months.
If you want a comparison, remember Ahed Tammimi, a 16 year old girl who was gaoled for 8 months for slapping a soldier who was trespassing in the grounds of her house, after her cousin had been shot in the head. Slapping a soldier was worth one month less than murdering a Palestinian.
Azaria was let out of prison 2 days before his official release date in order that he could attend his brother’s wedding. Yet a mother who had lost her daughter was refused, on the whim of a sadistic prison service and political echelon, even the most basic kindness that one would expect in the face of the bereavement of one’s child.
Sadism and cruelty are institutionalised in Israel in the all embracing fight against Palestinian resistance, which they term ‘terrorism’.
I remember a talk some years ago by Raja Shehada in Brighton and his description of the ‘meanness’ of Israelis who, during the Palestinian hunger strike in April 2017, set up a barbecue outside Ofer prison in order to torment the prisoners.
Even during the IRA hunger strikes of the 1980s, no Loyalist engaged in such a calculated act of sadism. And then there were the Israelis who set up sofas and a coffee machine on the hills above Gaza in order that they could get a better view of the bombing of civilians below. ‘Israelis Watch Bombs Drop on Gaza From Front-Row Seats’, NYT, 14.7.14.
People sometimes gib at comparing Nazi Germany to Zionist Israel but is there any more exact comparison? Some even call it ‘anti-Semitic’!
When the holocaust began in the wake of Operation Barbarossa in June 1941 Jews were murdered by the Einsatzgruppen killing squads under the heading of ‘bandits’ or ‘terrorists’. Calling one’s opponents ‘terrorists’ has long been the siren call of colonialists.
Zionists often say that Israel cannot be compared to Nazi Germany because, after all, whatever else they have done they have not exterminated the Palestinians. But that misses the point. A large section of Israeli Jewry, certainly larger than the equivalent part of the German population, would have no hesitation in exterminating the Palestinians if the political opportunity arose and they thought they could get away with it.
When thousands of settlers, young and old, take part in Jerusalem’s annual March of the Flags and then parade through the Arab part of East Jerusalem chanting ‘Death to the Arabs’ (Ma’avet La’Aravim) we should take them at their word. Even if Israel cannot find the opportunity for mass murder on an industrial scale no one should pretend that the mentality that enables such acts isn’t already present.
Although Khalida was not able to attend the funeral of her beloved Suha, thousands of Palestinians took her place in Ramallah before demonstrating outside Ofer prison. In so doing they ensured that in her mother’s absence, Suha was laid to rest with the love of thousands. The squalid hatreds of Zionism was met with the love of the people.
The following letter from Khalida was read out at her funeral:
As Anat Mater and Jonathan Pollak wrote in Ha’aretz :
Jarrar is one of the greatest feminist, socialist and anti-colonial revolutionaries the Palestinian people have been blessed with, and she is recognized and respected by the international community. Irrespective of the death of her daughter, she should be released immediately from her political imprisonment, which will be ending, one way or another, in three months anyway.
Of course there is a difference. Ami Popper is a Kahanist who murdered 7 random Arabs whose only crime was their ethnicity. Originally sentenced to a whole life imprisonment, his sentence was reduced first to 40 years and he will now be released after 33 years. Palestinians who kill a single Israeli Jew can expect 40 years in prison.
The Zionists, like their Afrikaaner allies before them, are nothing if not stupid. Indeed they are even more stupid because at least the Afrikaaners knew when it was time to give up on a system based on racial superiority. They also released another ‘terrorist’ by the name of Nelson Mandela. The Zionists prefer the ways of their hero who who died in a bunker in Berlin.
The reason why the Zionists are particularly stupid is that in their unreconstructed vengeance it isn’t Khalida, with her quiet and poignant suffering who has suffered the most but the Zionists themselves. They have shown themselves to be a slow-witted and vicious cult whose only delight is in tormenting the vulnerable. Politically they have done themselves more damage than Khalida could ever have managed.
Below is an appropriate article from Gideon Levy in Ha’aretz.
Damn them all. Damn Rafael Gana, the deputy head of the Israel Prison Service, who wrote to the interior minister: “Your request does not meet the prerequisites for consideration.” Damn Katy Perry, the head of the Israel Prison Service, who approved the decision. Damn Public Security Minister Omer Bar Lev, the heartless coward, who didn’t lift a finger to change this evil decision. And above all, damn the Shin Bet, which probably stands behind the decision, as it stands behind far more than we know.
Damn all those who are partner to this sadistic decision not to release Khalida Jarrar from prison to attend her daughter’s funeral. Damn this new government, which presumed to herald a change, and none of whose ministers acted to oppose the evil institutions that decided to leave Jarrar in prison. Not even ministers Merav Michaeli and Tamar Zandberg, who presumably have far more in common with the secular feminist freedom fighter Jarrar than with their colleague Ayelet Shaked.
And damn the Israeli media, which, with the exception of this newspaper, took no interest in the story, which was reported worldwide but not in Israel. Jarrar is a political prisoner. After a sequence of arrests without trial, she was sentenced to two years in prison for “belonging to an illegal organization,” in a land where there is no organization that is permitted to Palestinians. Jarrar is scheduled to be released September 25, about two months from now. All the existential dangers that lie in wait for the country upon her release will be ready to pounce in another two months.
On Sunday, her daughter Suha was found dead, apparently from cardiac arrest. Suha’s body was found about five hours after her death, after her sister in Canada was unable to reach her by phone and asked friends to break into the house. Suha’s father Ghassan was in Jenin at the time and rushed to her home. The Khalidas have two daughters: Suha, who completed a master’s degree in climate change in Canada and worked for the Al Haq human rights group in Ramallah, and Yafa, who completed a doctorate in law in Canada and lives there.
I will never forget that moment in the military court in Ofer in the summer of 2015: Yafa, Suha and Ghassan in the audience, Khalida in the dock, and the Israel Prison Service officer, Bassam Kashkush, suddenly allowed the two young women to approach their mother and embrace her. Even the warden teared up. It was forbidden, against regulations, but what Officer Kashkush dared to permit, in a rare moment of humanity and compassion, the State of Israel, the head of the Prison Service and the interior minister failed to do.
All that was needed was a tiny degree of humanity. All that was missing was a minimal amount of humanity. “He had a mother, after all,” wrote poet Nathan Alterman. They are also parents, after all, Katy and Omer and the Shin Bet agents. Are they capable of imagining what it means to lose a young daughter and not be able to go to her funeral? Not to be with her father and sister during their tragedy? To mourn in grief in a cell in Damon Prison? To hear about the death of their daughter on Radio Palestine?
What else? What else needs to be said about Israeli insensitivity, except for one thing: Jarrar is a human being. But to most Israelis, she isn’t. She’s a terrorist, although she has never been convicted of terrorism, and she is a proud Palestinian, and that is even worse, apparently.
The day after Suha’s death, when there was still hope that Jarrar would be released, the banquet hall in the center of Ramallah was filled with people. The entire secular left of the city came to be with Ghassan, who remained so alone in his mourning. He cried and cried, and everyone cried with him. Fadwa Barghouti, Marwan’s wife, who sat next to me, said their son Aarab was at this moment visiting his father in prison for the first time since the outbreak of the coronavirus. He is the only one in the family allowed to visit Marwan. Fadwa is not allowed to visit her husband, and Khalida is not allowed to attend her daughter’s funeral. Israeli malevolence, how awful it is.