This is a passionate
and breathless article by Gideon Levy, who with Amira Hass is Ha’aretz’s most
dedicated and committed columnists. Ha’aretz
is the sole liberal Israeli daily, but many of its columnists are anything but
During the slaughter
of the innocents in Operation Protective Edge in 2014, Gideon Levy was one of
5% of Israelis who opposed what was happening.
When he went to Ashdod in the South of Israel to report on what was
happening he was nearly lynched by a mob and had to be rescued by security.
mood in Israel was summed up by a popular slogan on the streets: There’s
No School In Gaza, There Are No More Kids Left’ Israelis literally rejoiced in the killing of
Palestinian children. This is not an aberration. Anyone who understands Israeli society knows
that it is only superficially a democratic society. It has had a state of emergency ever since it
was formed. Censorship, administrative
detention without trial for 6 months renewable, torture, police brutality and
murder – as well as the ritual murder that Israeli Palestinians face – is what
passes for the norm in Israeli society.
sickness which Gideon Levy describes so well is what makes the debate over ‘anti-Semitism’
in the Labour Party – a naked attempt to cow supporters of the Palestinians so outrageous. Those trendy liberals in the Labour Party like
Owen Jones who sought to gain a pat on the head and avoid attention from the
identity politics that surround Zionism think that they can combine superficial
support for the Palestinians with opposition to ‘anti-Semitism’ – which is a
weapon that Zionism deploys against supporters of the Palestinians and anti-Zionists.
is why the racists of the Jewish Labour Movement and their Progress supporters
need to be faced down rather than flattered and pampered. In Brighton we have seen a whole clutch of
right-wingers, such as Council leader Warren Morgan and Emma Daniels (a racist
feminist) join the JLM, an affiliate of the World Zionist Organisation and the British
branch of the Israeli Labour Party.
passion and the anger of Gideon Levy, who is one of a diminishing band of
left-wing and anti-racist Israelis is unfortunately not matched by those who
pay lipservice to the Palestinians whilst dancing with Labour’s Zionists. I intend in a future blog to do a more
detailed and critical analysis of why Labour Zionism is no different in essence
from Likud and the right-wing of the Zionist movement.
Children look through a hole in the wall of a burned bedroom where three children were killed by a fire in Gaza City, May 7, 2016. Khalil Hamra, AP
killed 546 Palestinian children over the course of only 50 days in Gaza in
2014. Of those, 180 were babies and toddlers under the age of five
Gideon Levy Jul 27,
2016 7:08 PM
One hundred and
eighty babies and children up to the age of 5. One hundred and eighty helpless
babies and toddlers that the Israel Defense Forces killed in Gaza in the 2014 Israel-Gaza
conflict. In their sleep, in their play, as they fled; in their beds or in
their parents’ arms.
Try to imagine – the
army killed 546 children in the course of 50 days. More than 10 children a day,
a classroom every three days. Try to imagine.
But these updated,
verified figures, released by the B’Tselem NGO on the second anniversary of the
killing, are hard to imagine. It’s easier to dismiss them with a shrug, a look
in the other direction or the lame excuses of Israeli propaganda.
The figures that
should have haunted Israeli society and keep it awake at night – that should
have sparked a stormy public debate and shaken it– are of no interest at all.
Any natural disaster at the end of the world would have evoked more human
feelings here than this slaughter, which Israel committed an hour’s drive from
By comparison – 84
Israeli children, horrific, were killed in the difficult eight years from the
start of the second intifada to Operation Cast Lead in Gaza in 2008; 546
Palestinian children were killed over 50 days in the summer of 2014.
They weren’t killed
by the hand of God. Ideological pilots, conscientious artillerymen, humane tank
crews and moral infantrymen killed them at the order of their no-less virtuous
They didn’t kill them
in a real war, facing a significant military force, nor in a war of no choice.
They killed most of them with bombs from the air or by shells from a distance,
without even seeing them. In most cases all they saw was their tiny figures playing
on the beach, huddling in their shabby homes, sleeping or running for their
lives on the sophisticated computer screens and joy sticks of the no less
sophisticated soldiers and pilots. They didn’t mean to kill them, but they
pressed the button and killed them. Hundreds of soldiers who killed hundreds of
Two years later, the
huge headline “The parents’ outcry” (in Yediot Ahronoth yesterday) doesn’t, of
course, refer in any way to the outcry of the bereaved parents over there.
Israel has never paid any heed to its actions there. If a commission of inquiry
is set up to look into the Gaza conflict, it will be over the tunnels.
Israel hasn’t even
looked straight at the facts and confessed. It was all for security’s sake,
inevitable, Israel is the victim, they are Satan, that’s how it is in war,
that’s how it always is – a 100 times more Palestinian fatalities than Israeli
ones in Cast Lead, 30 times more in the 2014 conflict. (“So, did you want more
Israelis to be killed?”)
This ghastly lack of proportion
doesn’t raise any question or doubt, not to mention criticism. Nor does what’s
left – 90,000 residents still homeless, living for the past two years among the
debris or in wretched tin huts. A Swedish journalist who visited Gaza for a few
days last week returned with the pictures – tin boxes housing people whose
homes were destroyed in Huza’a, near Khan Yunis.
There’s no point in
continuing to describe the magnitude of the disaster in Gaza. It’s of no
concern to anyone in Israel. Human compassion over Gaza? Funny. Even the fact
that, due to the bombardments and the siege, 90 million liters of raw sewage
flow from Gaza into the Mediterranean Sea, the same sea our children bathe in,
doesn’t bother anyone here.
inconceivable how Israelis can go on being so pleased with themselves and their
army in view of the facts of the 2014 Israel-Gaza conflict. How come, even as
time goes by, their stomachs don’t turn, if only for a minute? What can we make
of people who say seriously about an army that killed hundreds of children only
two years ago, that it’s the most moral army in the world? And what should we
make of the society and state that has this as its discourse?